1. Untitled Chapter
  2. Introduction
  3. Setting the Table
  4. A Crisis of Thirst
  5. Sinjar's Astronauts
Chad Bouchard and 100Reporters

Tainted Waters

Tainted Waters
Introduction

Starting in late spring this year, cities and towns in northwestern Iraq began to fall, one by one, into the hands of a violent religious movement, the Islamic State. The group swallowed up areas along the Euphrates and Tigris rivers, quickly plunging the region into fierce conflict and a brutal humanitarian nightmare.

Due in part to U.S. airstrikes, the creeping advance appears to be stanched for the moment, and Kurdish forces have reclaimed a small number of towns that had been overrun.

One of Islamic State’s recent prizes is Sinjar, a rural community comprised mainly of minority groups including Yazidis, who practice a syncretic mix of Islam and ancient beliefs that the hardliners consider to be heretical.  

According to some reports, hundreds of Yazidis were executed for refusing to convert to Islam. Hundreds of thousands more fled to escape violence and mistreatment, only to face deadly conditions while hiding in nearby mountains. 

Before the group seized Sinjar, this community had long suffered from a failing local  government and widespread distrust of the regime in Baghdad. Their chief complaint was widespread corruption. In many of its conquests, Islamic State has exploited discontent over corruption, lack of security and poor governance to recruit young fighters to join their campaign.

In late 2013, as Islamic State was building forces to fuel its recent surge of violence, 100Reporters visited Sinjar to investigate allegations of corruption in the district’s essential water systems. Drinking water was making people sick, as untreated groundwater was pumped from wells through leaky pipes and directly into homes. An audit showed that government officials were siphoning money from local budgets meant to fix the problem.

The U.S. government spent millions of dollars to dig wells and pipelines in the area, but allegedly failed to keep tabs on a project that in the end only benefited foreign contractors. A close look at conditions before the fall of Sinjar reveals a city hamstrung by graft and mired in resentment, and paints an early, intimate portrait of how its citizens paid for their government’s shortcomings.

Setting the Table

In 2006, the U.S. State Department funded a project to dig 48 wells across the district of Sinjar. After a call for bids on the project, the government hired a construction company based in Jordan, Civilian Technologies Limited, to take on the job. 

A visit to one part of the Sinjar Water Project on the outskirts of the city revealed serious shortcomings. A tank was choked with algae and generators were rusting, while leaky pipes spewed water back into the sand. 

This complex of 10 wells was supposed to supply water through a pipeline to two villages more than a dozen miles away, but five years after its completion, the 8,000 families living there had yet to see a drop of clean water for the effort.

Sayeed Khalaf, a 50-something operator who also owns the land on which the wells were built, said the contractor was slow and sloppy.

“The company worked without any pressure, and no supervision,” he said.

Multiple attempts to seek comment from Civilian Technologies by phone and email at their offices in Amman and Baghdad were unsuccessful. 

Khalaf recalled talking to a crew from the American military who came to check on progress in 2008. They had heard complaints about the lack of water, and seemed unhappy with the state of the project – asking why it wasn’t working, Khalaf said.

“The problem with the Americans is that they were stubborn and opinionated,” said Dakhil Qassim Hassoun, who served as the mayor of Sinjar from 2003 to 2010, during the bulk of the American reconstruction.

“They wanted to deal with the contractors directly, without checking with the [city] administration or other parties that were involved,” he said.

Pipes leaked from a well built with U.S. funds from 2006 to 2008. Photo: Sami Hilali
Sayeed Khalaf, owner of land where the water project was built, worked as a guard for the facility, which is not connected to nearby towns and remains without power five years after it was completed. Photo: Chad Bouchard
A plastic bag used as a stopper in a reservoir tank at an abandoned U.S.-funded project. Photo: Sami Hilali
A fitting connected to an unused water tank rusts, after the project was handed over to the Iraqi government. Photo: Sami Hilali
The granddaughter of Guli Khalaf, in the courtyard of her home in Sinjar. Photo: Sami Hilali

Hassoun described the project as plagued with problems from the beginning. There wasn’t enough electric capacity to run all of the equipment, transformers failed, and pipes were perpetually leaky, he said. The contractor secured all of the materials for the project, from diesel engines to the plastic pipelines, from overseas suppliers. They hired unskilled local laborers but ignored advice from local geologists, who had taken water samples and warned against digging at some sites because the water wouldn’t be potable, Hassoun said.

“We told them, ‘If you dig one of these wells, the people will never benefit from it.’ They said, ‘We will dig, and you as a local government will go ahead and buy equipment to sweeten the water.’”

He said that the Americans didn’t supervise the project closely, and lacked the authority to enforce deadlines or standards. Asked who did have such powers, Hassoun shrugged.

The picture Hassoun painted matches up with Bowen’s findings. The special inspector general conducted five “asset transfer” audits to track the handover.

“Hundreds of projects were being turned over by the Army Corps of Engineers that the Iraqis did not want. They were simply given to them despite their palpable rejection,” Bowen said in an interview. The audit reports recommended more coordination among all the reconstruction agencies and with locals, but in the end it was “an oversight effort on our part that had insufficient impact,” he said.

Amid the chaos, funds were lost, projects looted for parts, and corruption took hold like a bad infection in a wound.

In 2008, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers foresaw the risks in the Sinjar water system's handoff. 

The "future security and economic situation in this region is precarious," U.S. project engineer Michael Miller was quoted as saying in a press release at the time. "It would be a shame to see their water supply suffer because of neglect.”  

"The problem with the Americans is that they were stubborn and opinionated."

Charles Teifer, a professor of government contracting at the University of Baltimore Law School who led a Congressional commission on wartime contracting, said disorganization set the table and left projects open to a feeding frenzy of graft.

“You turn it over to something that was called ‘the Iraqis.’ There’s an authority from Baghdad, and they say ‘We’re the Iraqis,’ and there’s a local authority and they say ‘We’re the Iraqis,’” he said. The State Department “basically couldn’t force the Iraqis to do an orderly handoff.”

In 2012, a small group of Iraq legislators, elected members of the Ninewa council, noticed the lack of progress on water projects. After an investigation, signs of corruption quickly started surfacing.

“You can see it in the quality of the pipeline itself,” said Hassan Omar, a journalist who served as an assistant in the investigation. The 12-mile pipeline was shallow and made of shoddy plastic instead of durable PVC, he said, evidence that the contractors intentionally cut corners to boost profits.

“They didn't dig down enough, they didn't cover it with sand, they only dug 20 centimeters, and back-filled with dirt and rocks. And the pipe cracked,” he said.

U.S. Sinjar Water Project: A Case Study in Poor Oversight

Perhaps more damning is that while the contractor used shoddy materials to apparently squeeze extra profits out of the project, officials from Sinjar, including the city council and the mayor’s office, approved the project after it was completed. The work fell short of requirements in the original project tender, but the city, which was required to inspect the work, rubber-stamped the project. 

“In other places, the wells were dug, they hired a biology firm who said the water was potable, but after digging we discovered that it wasn’t. Yet the Ninewa water department came and signed for the project,” said Hassoun. 

He said he sent a letter to the provincial government saying the project was overreaching and would cost too much to run. The province never responded.

Hassoun is convinced that digging wells is an unsustainable solution. The water table is dropping, and the population has outgrown its ability to pull enough water from the ground.

The only way to quench the city’s growing thirst, he said, is to divert the mighty Tigris River, more than 50 miles away. 

A Crisis of Thirst

“Our water smells like chlorine and frogs,” said Guli Khalaf, a 45-year-old resident of Sinjar and mother of 11 children.

She cupped the right side of her abdomen, describing searing pain she felt from kidney stones since the age of 18.

“I have just lived with it, doing the things a mother does, like baking bread in a traditional mud oven, even working on a farm,” she said. “But sometimes I would get dizzy. My hands would shake and I would cry out in pain. I couldn’t even walk, so I would crawl.”

U.S. taxpayers paid $60 billion to boost security and rebuild Iraqi infrastructure destroyed during the invasion. 

But results have fallen far short of the mark. American auditors found that slack oversight led to shoddy work, and poor planning left a fifth of that money wide open for abuse. Massive investments meant to improve Iraqis’ quality of life have ended up reinforcing a system that works against their best interests.

A few years ago, Khalaf’s doctor discovered that one of her kidneys was packed with dozens of stones. “Do you have a whole mountain in there?” she remembered him joking.

Local doctors said the rate of kidney stones in Sinjar was “fifteen times higher” than in other parts of the province, with 22,000 cases reported in a single year, from a population of 40,000.  For comparison, a recent study indicated that about one in 11 people in the United States will develop a kidney stone. 

No one is sure what's behind the unusually high incidence of kidney stones. Tests on well samples from one Iraqi researcher showed that the levels of calcium, magnesium and other minerals exceed international guidelines. But the science underlying the relationship between these minerals and stones is complicated and unsettled. While too much calcium can cause kidney stones, alkaline minerals also detected in Sinjar’s water may have the opposite effect – making stones less likely to form. 

To make up for the crippled municipal water system, many Sinjar residents were forced to buy water from trucks such as this one, which drew water from wells that are not tested for bacteria or haards, and were only occasionally treated with chlorine tablets. Photo: Sami Hilali
Guli Khalaf, 45, a lifelong resident of Sinjar and mother of 7 girls and 4 boys. Her kidney problems began when she was 18 years old. Photo: Chad Bouchard
Patients leaving a clinic in Sinjar, where doctors reported high rates of water-related illnesses like diarrhea, typhoid fever and brucellosis. Photo: Sami Hilali
Residents paid workers from a private company to pump water from an old reservoir miles from the town of Sinjar. Photo: Sami Hilali
Sinjar is a ancient city, with nearby archaeological sites dating back 6,000 years. After the U.S. invasion in 2003, the population grew exponentially as people migrated north to escape the fighting. Photo: Sami Hilali
Until the Islamic State incursion, about half of the people living in the Sinjar district belonged to an ethnic and religious minority known as Yazidi, many of whom fled when Islamic State threatened to kill those who would not convert to Islam. Photo: Sami Hilali

But dehydration and a hot climate are known risk factors for kidney stones. When people don’t get enough water to drink – or don’t want to drink the water they have due to its smell or taste – stones are more likely to accrete out of the concentrated urine and collect in the kidneys. 

Sinjar sits in one of Iraq’s most water-starved regions, more than 50 miles from the Tigris, one of the country’s two great rivers. Conditions have worsened under two crushing droughts over the last decade, and city officials say the water table is dropping rapidly. The remaining stores are wide open to contamination before reaching households. The city’s sewage system is nonexistent, and the plumbing is falling apart. Leaky pipes run next to open sewers and under pools of fetid grey water. Toilets are perilously close to wells. 

Dr. Zaki Sayid, a senior physician at Sinjar Public Hospital, blamed the water for kidney stones as well as widespread cases of waterborne bacterial disease like diarrhea and typhoid. He said he first encountered the problem soon after moving from the provincial capital of Mosul to Sinjar along with other physicians several years ago.

“In the first six months to a year, we just drank water from the city’s pipelines like we had in Mosul. Until we got infected – us, the doctors – from kidney stones. Then we had to treat ourselves.”

The doctor switched to bottled water, like most Iraqis with the means to pay for it. But with an estimated expense of $100 per month, bottled water is out of reach for Guli Khalaf (no relation to Sayeed) and most of the residents of Sinjar. Caught between foul-smelling water and financial strain, the people of Sinjar remained chronically parched. 

According to a 2011 report from UNICEF, more than 73 percent of households in rural Iraq did not have enough chlorine in their drinking water to fend off disease, and more than 15.4 percent of children under five had suffered from diarrhea within two weeks of the survey’s snapshot. Diarrhea remains the leading cause of child death in the country.

Lots of money has been spent on wells and pipes to fix the problem, but results have been shockingly scant.

Because of weak oversight and poor planning, $11.7 billion of the U.S. reconstruction funds was vulnerable to waste and graft, a U.S. special inspector general said. About $15 billion of that money was spent on infrastructure – roads, schools, power and water. The final report from Inspector General Stewart Bowen in 2013 concludes that reconstruction money spent with barely any oversight fueled the rise of corruption. 

Sinjar's Astronauts

The area's water crisis extends to nearby Qahataniya, a dust-swept town about 10 miles southeast of Sinjar. The site started as a camp Saddam Hussein created when he forcibly relocated the Yazidis from nearby mountain homes in 1975. In 2003, refugees fled north to escape violence as U.S. forces pressed from the south, some landing in small towns like Qahataniya where services were already stretched.

American post-war efforts to drill wells and improve water systems did not extend to this town, so it was up to the Iraqi government to bolster the dwindling supply of clean, safe water. Their results were no better.

Investigators from Ninewa’s provincial council included Qahataniya in their corruption investigation, and the details provide a backstage look at the techniques used to siphon money from projects.

Fed up with what they saw as a corrupt and stagnant government, residents decided to strike out on their own. They reclaimed abandoned water projects, and dug new wells at their own expense.

In 2012, the provincial government of Ninewa dug 26 wells in Qahataniya and two neighboring towns, complete with pump houses, generators and a network of pipes. The wells were tested for waterborne diseases, and all but one of them got good marks for potability.

Like the American-sponsored project in Sinjar, however, the system in Qahataniya never worked. It was rife with odd little technical problems that “even a child should know how to fix,” said one of the investigators, Ninewa provincial council member Dawood Jundy Sulaiman.

Generators lacked batteries, parts were missing from pumps, and power lines from the town’s electric grid mysteriously end in the dirt. 

“And yet, there are thousands of meters of cable sitting in the stock rooms of electricity departments,” Sulaiman said.

The generators sat idle. But Qahtaniya got an allotment of diesel fuel to run them – 35,000 liters (9,246 gallons) per month, according to government documents.

“I asked the people who are in charge: Do you bottle this fuel so you can give it to the people to drink?” Sulaiman said, and snorted.

Sayeed Ali Jinder, an elementary school teacher in Qahtaniya, said he was “deeply disappointed” in the district and state government. Photo: Chad Bouchard
Effluent trickled out of well-drilling equipment that residents were using to dig a private water supply. Photo: Sami Hilali
Qahataniya Mayor Khdir Khadidah Rashow rejected the notion that corruption was holding back the progress of a long-delayed water project, and said he did not know anything about the project's missing funds. Photo: Sami Hilali
Mrad Ilyas Hassan is one of the well operators residents have hired informally to reclaim old and abandoned government water facilities. Photo: Chad Bouchard
Each pipe from this well connected to a household in a Qahataniya neighborhood. The system was an informal solution devised by residents who have lost faith in their city’s government. Photo: Sami Hilali
On August 14th 2007, four powerful bombs ripped through Qahataniya, including a market near this memorial. The blasts killed nearly 800 people and wounded more than 1,500 others. The incident was thought to be a coordinated al-Qaeda attack on the Yazidi population, which the group considers to be “infidels.” No affiliated groups claimed responsibility, but the Yazidis again became targets when Islamic State stormed the town in August 2014. Photo: Chad Bouchard

According to government documents, the water department of Qahataniya paid 23 employees to operate the wells over the last year.

“Where are these employees? Nobody knows. It seems the department head is hiding his employees,” said Hassan Omar.

In Arabic, these “ghost employees” are known as fda'ey, or “astronauts,” because their feet never touch the ground.

“How can you steal and be corrupt in a project that will benefit a lot of people?" asked Sulaiman. "Just so you can make money and have your son drinking only bottled water while at the same time there are other kids drinking water that may be mixed with sewage?” 

Confronted about missing money in the mouldering project, the mayor of Qahataniya in 2013, Khdir Khadidah Rashow, said he did not know the project’s budget numbers, or how much money was spent.

“That is out of my jurisdiction,” he said. “The last stage of the project, the last contract, was finished a year ago. So we’ve been negotiating with officials to hire people to manage the project.”

Like other government officials in the area, he insisted there was just not enough groundwater to go around. He said that wells are only a temporary solution and the government must invest in a $250 million project to divert the Tigris. 

"Where are these employees? Nobody knows. It seems the department head is hiding his employees."

“Are 600,000 people not worth $250 million? Of course they are,” he said.

His stance echoed that of mayors in Sinjar and other villages. Local government appeared fixated on expensive, long-term solutions.

He was adamant that corruption has not played a role in the town’s foundering water facilities, though he could not guarantee, he said, that the contract’s details and terms were entirely above board. He described the year-long pause in deploying the well operators  as a “sign of protest,” a bid to pressure Ninewa to pay salaries for 12 more employees.

Far from the mayor’s office, in a muddy neighborhood near the town’s center, residents were certain that the project’s shortcomings were rooted in corruption. 

Fed Up: Neighbors Forge Ahead Without Government Help

“They steal the money,” said Farhan Khalili, a resident of Qahataniya who once worked as a translator for the U.S. Army, and now works as a police K9 trainer. “They get money to make a sewage system or another service, but they do nothing for us.”

Nearby, a noisy drilling machine pounded its way into the desert soil. A group of neighbors had pooled their own money to hire a private company to dig a new well, at a cost of 1 million Iraqi Dinars, or about $860. It was unclear whether the neighbors planned to test the water for minerals or pathogens.

Sayeed Ali Jinder, an elementary school teacher, blamed everyone in government for the failure to deliver water, from the mayor’s office to the provincial council and Baghdad.

“Every time a budget gets passed and money gets assigned to complete the project, they never complete it," he said. "It’s been ten years, and no progress worth mentioning.”

In another neighborhood, residents hired their own operator, Mrad Ilyas Hassan, who worked for the town until 2010, to manage an aging well dug in 1979. He used a clunky diesel engine to pump water for a few hours per day. The residents pay 1,000 to 5,000 dinars per month, between about 80 cents and $4.30, for the right to draw this water from pipes every other day.

Iraq produces some 3 million barrels of oil per day, but more than 7 million Iraqis get by on only $2.20 per day, according to the United Nations.

A tangled network of hoses and pipes sprouts from the old well reservoir and runs to each of the houses. Neighborhood children hang from the pipes, turning it into a makeshift jungle gym.

“Of course I’m angry,” said Hassan. “It’s upsetting to see people buying water and carrying it down the street on their shoulders. If there is no water, what is a citizen going to do?”

Additional reporting by Narin Shamo.

This project was made possible through a grant from the Fund for Investigative Journalism.

PHOTO CREDITS FOR CHAPTER IMAGES: Top: Chad Bouchard; Setting the Table: Sami Hilali; A Crisis of Thirst: Sami Hilali; Sinjar's Astronauts: Samil Hilali